
It’s appropriate that “Smokin’ Aces” worst subpolot involves a hyperactive, goofy kid who hasn’t taken his ritalin. The whole film sort of plays that way; a mishmash of shifting topics and tempo that could give anyone not prepared a severe headache.
The splattery, profane mania is hardly original, as anyone who hasn’t already forgotten last years “Running Scared” or 2005’s “Domino” can attest. But writer/director Joe Carnahan somehow makes it seem fresh, as if the self-congratulatory, quirky dialogue and shock-value laced noise constitute something we haven’t already experienced (or avoided) many times over.
The canvas for the mayhem is simple enough before the plot twists complicate it. Jeremy Piven plays Buddy “Aces” Israel, a sleazy Las Vegas magician holed up in a hooker-laden hotel suite while waiting to testify against the mob. When a million-dollar contract is taken out on his heart (specifically his heart), a screwy assortment of lawmen, hitmen, bondsmen and hotel men converge on the same location, chaos bound to ensue. Agents Messner (Ryan Reynolds) and Carruthers (Ray Liotta) are the FBI men charged with protecting Israel from the disguise experts, torture nuts, lesbian snipers, and psychotic Nazis that have arrived to make a fortune from offing the magician.
A massive, star-filled cast brings the 30 or so characters to life. The roster includes Ben Affleck, Jason Bateman, Matthew Fox, Andy Garcia, and Alicia Keys, just to name the more recognizable ones. Most of them are colorfully slaughtered in massive shootout we know to be coming by watching the trailer. It’s a very cool, visually complex battle, with several dozen people trading gunfire and chainsaw swings across two buildings and several floors. Unfortunately, though the last shot gets fired too soon, a bit of a letdown considering the wait.
Though Carnahan more or less denies any Quentin Tarantino influence, the notes are familiar, such as when characters have rapid-fire discussions about prostitutes or Clinton-esque jacket stains. Unlike a Tarantino film (“Pulp Fiction” most obviously), the conversations and outlandish characterizations never click together, instead existing in their own space without significantly contributing to mood or theme. “Smokin Aces” winds up resembling a bunch of good short films combined with a couple of bad ones to create one okay feature length picture. A few of the subplots should have been scrapped altogether, adding nothing but filler. By the time we arrive at the curiously somber ending, it has alternated between taking itself too seriously and not seriously enough. And with roughly ten minutes dedicated to each character, how does Carnahan expect us to care when he decides to cue the sad music?
Nonetheless, I kind of liked it. Carnahan is definitely a very talented filmmakers, or else this screenplay factory explosion would be unwatchable. Even with a running time of 108 minutes, it feels like 90, and never gets boring until the finale’s lengthy plot exposition. The lack of focus is crippling, though. I couldn’t tell what Carnahan was shooting for, and I suspect that he doesn’t know either. But I sort of like where he’s heading.
2.5 out of 5


