
In 2003, a criminally overlooked film called "Shattered Glass" was released. A fusion of biopic, drama, and thriller, it told the true story of a Stephen Glass, a popular journalist who fabricated many of his stories. The film’s great strength was that Glass was shown from the perspective of those around him, never diving into his psyche or offering a concrete explanation as to why he did what he did, leaving that up to the audience’s imagination.
"Breach" is the follow up film of Billy Ray, who also wrote and directed "Shattered Glass." There are many similarities; both tell a recent true story, are centered around the sins of one man, refuse to delve into detailed explanations of his psyche, and unfold through the eyes of his colleagues. The key difference is where the journalist of the former film only deserved to be fired, the subject of this one deserves a fate worse than death.
Chris Cooper stars as Robert Hanssen, a long-time FBI agent who in 2001 was arrested for selling secrets to the Soviet Union and later Russia. The damage he caused was catastrophic, resulting in the deaths of at least a few valuable spies and untold other losses.
If the film is to be believed, it’s easy to see how he fooled those around him. Hanssen’s outward personality is that of a devout Catholic who attends mass daily, a feverish patriot honored to serve his country. On the other hand, we have a cunning double agent that sells the nation’s secrets for stacks of $100 bills and trades sex tapes of him and his wife that were recorded with a hidden camera. Except for when he steals documents and corresponds with his handler, these personalities seem completely separate, two entirely different individuals residing in the same shell.
As part of their sting operation, the FBI assigns Eric O’Neill (Ryan Phillippe) to work underneath Hanssen and to take meticulous notes so that a solid case can be built. At first, O’Neill is only told the investigation concerns Hanssen being a "sexual deviant." Despite several thorny exchanges, he begins to admire Hanssen, who appears to be a model public servant and dedicated family man. But after being introduced to the true nature of his assignment, as well as the dozens of fellow agents working on it, O’Neill struggles to maintain the trust of the man who prides himself on being able to detect the smallest lie.
Cooper’s complex performance would likely be generated Oscar buzz if the film were released during Oscar season. Since the audience goes in knowing the back story, it’s up to the actors to inject importance into the proceedings, and the first rate cast that also includes Gary Cole, Dennis Haysbert, and Laura Linney does a remarkably good job. The screen crackles with enthrallment whenever Hanssen and O’Neill interact, though the younger man’s side story, involving his impatient wife (Caroline Dhavernas), tends to bring the momentum to a screeching halt so the two can feud.
But while the performances are more notable and the topic matter vastly more important, "Breach" never quite reaches the level that "Shattered Glass" did. Both films avoid the "why," but while we can use our imaginations for Glass, Hanssen’s misdeeds and character flaws and endlessly more complicated. Ray has difficulty handling such a perplexing figure, one who could handle a treasonous double life for decades before it came to an end. Do we really need to know why Hanssen did what he did? Maybe, maybe not, but for crimes this bad and a man this vile, I’d sure like to hear it.
3.5 out of 5
